If you are planning to immigrate to Canada, you may be aware that language proficiency is one of the immigration requirements. High results on the language proficiency test can in fact make a big difference in your Express Entry Comprehensive Ranking Score, especially when applying without an offer of arranged employment or Provincial Nomination.
There are two options to meet English language skills requirements: taking the Canadian English Language Proficiency Index Program (CELPIP) or the International English Language Testing System (IELTS) test. Both tests are accepted by Citizenship and Immigration Canada; the question is, which is the best test for you?
![Untitled design (2)]()
About the Tests
Both IELTS and CELPIP are designed to measure the English language proficiency of test-takers. The tests include four categories that capture the main aspects of the language: Listening, Reading, Writing and Speaking.
IELTS is used for study, work and immigration. It recognizes both British and American English for spelling, word choice and grammar, and uses a mix of accents from native speakers throughout the test. IELTS is available in more than 140 countries and is divided into IELTS Academic (used for education) and IELTS General Training (used for migration to an English-speaking country). If you are taking IELTS to apply through Express Entry, the IELTS General Training test is required.
CELPIP test was designed specifically to assess key language skills required for Canadian permanent residency and citizenship. The test uses Canadian English and accepts both British and American English spellings for its components. If you are taking CELPIP to apply through Express Entry, the CELPIP-General (four-skills tests) is required.
IELTS and CELPIP are both approved and accepted by Citizenship and Immigration Canada (CIC). The final test score is compared to the Canadian Language Benchmark (CLB), which demonstrates national language standards for recognizing a second language. To receive any points for Express Entry, the candidate should be able to score a CLB of 4 – 5, equivalent to a moderate proficiency in a daily context. To have a competitive Express Entry profile, a CLB score of 7 or higher is recommended (a CLB 7 score is equivalent to CELPIP 7 and IELTS 6.0 in each of the 4 test categories).
Below is a comparison table of the key components of the tests:
|
CELPIP
|
IELTS
|
Score breakdown |
- A score of 1 to 12 for each section; calibrated against the Canadian Language Benchmarks (CLB) levels
|
- A score of 1 to 9 for each section; can score whole (e.g., 6.0, 7.0) or half (e.g., 6.5, 7.5) bands
|
Listening |
- 47 minutes; 7 components, a total of 46-49 questions
|
- ~30 minutes; 4 components, a total of 40 questions
|
Reading |
- 60 minutes; 5 components, 46 questions
|
- 60 minutes; 3 components, 40 questions
|
Writing |
- 53 minutes; 2 components: Writing an Email and Responding to Survey Questions
|
- 60 minutes; 2 components: Writing a Letter and Responding to a Point of View, Argument or Problem
|
Speaking |
- 20 minutes; 8 components, a total of 8 short-answer questions
|
- ~11-14 minutes; 3 components: Introduction, Individual Speech and Two-Way Discussion
|
Details |
- The test times include the transition times between the test components
- Computer-based test
|
- The test times exclude the transition times between the test components
- Paper-based test
|
![exam]()
Making Your Choice
There are several factors to consider when choosing which test to take.
1. Location and Availability
Overall, CELPIP is more accessible in Canada. CELPIP has 33 locations across Canada, in all provinces except Prince Edward Island (the test locations are currently unavailable in the three Canadian territories YT, NU, NT). IELTS has 28 locations in five Canadian provinces (ON, QC, MB, AB and BC). On the other hand, only IELTS is available outside of Canada.
The availability for both tests is given months in advance, so it is easy to plan ahead. The frequency with which the tests are offered depend on the province and the city.
2. Price
CELPIP is a cheaper option: the price for CELPIP-General is $265. IELTS price in Canada is $295; however, in certain places in Canada, the fee is higher (e.g. $355 in Fort St John). Outside of Canada, IELTS has different prices, depending on the country in which it is offered.
3. Test and Result Times
The time it takes to finish both tests is approximately the same – around 3 hours. CELPIP is conducted in one sitting; and since it is done on the computer, it is easy to keep track of how much time is left for each of the tasks. When going by sections, CELPIP seems to have longer Listening and Speaking sections and a shorter Writing section. However, CELPIP time break-downs include the question, answer and transition times.
IELTS on the other hand, has three test sections that are completed in the same test room, but the Speaking section is done separately. The applicant may be required to complete the speaking test at a different time, day and possibly location. There also is no automatic computerized time tracking, therefore the times presented in the table above may not include the transition times between the test sections and components.
The results take 13 calendar days for IELTs and 10-12 calendar days for CELPIP. If you are short on time and money is not an issue, CELPIP also has express rating system; the score is available in three business days for an extra $100 fee.
4. Difficulty
Both IELTS and CELPIP were designed to measuring English language proficiency; the level of difficulty is approximately the same in both tests. However, certain sections can be viewed as easier or more difficult by individual test-takers.
There are a few differences that can be noted. Firstly, IELTS is a paper-based exam, while CELPIP is completely computerized. It may be more comforting for some people to do the writing section on paper and to keep track of their own time. Others, on the other hand, feel less pressure on the computer, and prefer to type and be able to see their timing and word count.
Secondly, IELTS includes native speaker from Australia, Canada, New Zealand, the UK and US in their Listening section, while CELPIP relies on Canadian speakers. Some non-native speakers may find the CELPIP Listening section more understandable. Also, when taking CELPIP, one is able to adjust the volume in the headphones for the Listening section to suit their needs.
Thirdly, the IELTS Speaking section includes a live conversation with an examiner, while during CELPIP you record your voice on the computer. Some non-native speakers may feel more comfortable without the face-to-face interaction.
5. Preparation
It may be easier to find preparation materials for IELTS, since CELPIP is still relatively new. Both exams, however, offer online samples of their work and have prep courses across Canada. CELPIP prep courses seem to be more prevalent in Canada.
|
CELPIP |
IELTs |
Availability |
- 33 locations in 9 provinces
- Not available outside of Canada
|
- 28 locations in 5 provinces
- Available in >140 countries
|
Price |
- $265 (CAD) + tax
- Express rating (3 business days) available for $100
|
- $295 (CAD) + tax
- Can be more expensive in certain locations
|
Time |
- 3-hour exam done in one sitting
- Results in 10-12 calendar days; express rating available
|
- ~3-hour exam; speaking is separate
- Results in 13 calendar days
|
Difficulty |
- Computer-based: easy to type; word count and timing available
- Using Canadian English accent; able to adjust the volume
- Speaking: submitting voice recording
|
- Paper-based: easier for non-frequent computer users
- Using British, Australian and American English accents
- Speaking: face-to-face interaction
|
Preparation |
- More prep courses available
|
- More preparation materials available
|
Summary
Both of the tests are equally appropriate to be used for your immigration application, and choosing one over the other can be a matter of personal preference. IELTS is a good choice for the test-takers who prefer paper-based exams and separate face-to-face speaking components, or are applying from outside of Canada. Based on the analysis above, however, CELPIP is a better choice for those who are looking for a faster, less stressful and less costly test experience.
Accredited CELPIP Preparation Program
Ashton College offers an Accredited CELPIP Preparation Program, designed to prepare students for individual components of the CELPIP-General and the CELPIP-General LS tests.
Find out More »
Subscribe
By entering your email below, you agree to receive articles from the Ashton College blog. We will not send you promotional materials or any other information. You can unsubscribe at any time.
The post CELPIP versus IELTS: Which One Should You Take? appeared first on Ashton College.